Amanda Machado is a writer who has traveled the world, spending much of that time living nomadically. The daughter of immigrants to the US, her travels have taken her around the world on a quest to explore identity and cultural heritage. Her work has been published in The Atlantic, Vox, Quartz, and Matador Network.
In 2016, I remember watching Michelle Obama’s speech at the Democratic National Convention where she said about the US “This right now is the greatest country on Earth.”
It was a comment I had heard many times in my life, not only in political speeches, but also by history teachers at school or parents of friends.
Growing up in the United States, the idea of the US as “the greatest country on Earth” seemed less like an opinion and more like an obvious fact.
Our school curriculums over-celebrated U.S. success (or, at very least, the success of Western civilizations), while downplaying our many mistakes. We very rarely learned about how U.S. political decisions may have affected other countries negatively.
With only this limited history of the world, I naturally assumed there was no country “better”.
Opening my eyes through travel.
Yet once I began traveling and having conversations with people abroad, it became clear that not everyone agreed.
Through traveling, instead of hearing only stories of U.S. greatness, I learned more about the many areas in which we’re behind: the United States is one of only three countries to not offer paid maternal leave for its citizens (Suriname and Papua New Guinea are the other two).
When it comes to gender representation in national government, the United States falls behind countries like Cuba, Nicaragua, Senegal, South Africa, Ecuador, Costa Rica and Mozambique. We have lower voter turnout than countries like Iran, the Central African Republic, Chad, Namibia, Yemen, and dozens of others. And the only country in the world that incarcerates a higher percentage of its population than the US is North Korea.
Differing perceptions from around the world.
After traveling, I also realized that few people perceived the US as the heroic helpers my U.S. education had portrayed ourselves to be.
Many instead saw us as a country that meddles too much in everybody’s business. When I traveled in Europe after the US began the war in Iraq, most people I spoke with criticized our military response.
When I traveled throughout Latin America, referring to the US as “imperialist” in conversations seemed commonplace. When I traveled to Cuba, I heard many stories of resentment towards U.S. foreign policy interventions that had ultimately killed members of their family.
Before traveling, I also assumed everyone around the world wanted some version of the American Dream, and shared my U.S. definition of what makes a country actually “great”: access to prestigious universities, opportunities to advance your career, the financial resources to buy things that make you live comfortably.
But as I wrote in a previous article for The Atlantic, many people I met while traveling had different priorities.
In Peru, I met a man who turned down a job in the US even though it offered more money. He told me:
“The social part of life is better here in Peru...My quality of life is what matters most.”
Others would point out the dismal statistics for depression and anxiety in the US. To them, sacrificing the emotional parts of their lives for more financial and professional opportunity didn’t seem worth it.
As Rick Steves, the popular travel guidebook writer and television host, said in an interview with Salon:
“It’s a very powerful Eureka! moment when you’re traveling: to realize that people don’t have the American dream. They’ve got their own dream. And that’s not a bad thing. That’s a good thing.”
At a time after the US president won a campaign based on making America “great again,” I’m now more critical of our obsession with believing we were so great in the first place. It seems far more beneficial instead to rethink our own definitions of what makes a country great, and get curious about how other countries have defined it for themselves.
Wise is the cheaper way to send money between countries.
If you're a US expat, a resident alien or you've moved to the US, check out this guide to know whether you're subject taxes, and find the best tips in 2023.
All you need to know about the US Foreign Tax Credit as an American expat.
Can you get an international student loan as a foreign student in the US? Find all you need to know — and the best options for you — in this handy guide.
Be it for temporary reasons or a more permanent pursuit of the “American Dream,” moving to the United States of America always entails a few adjustments —...
Moving to Europe is no doubt a ‘bucket list’ item for many people around the world. The history, diverse cultures and languages, and excellent quality of life...
Want to save money when you send Brazilian reais? There’s a smarter, cheaper way to send money internationally. When you convert currencies with traditional...